Plagiarism Prevention and Detection
How do we reconcile the importance of trusting our students with the knowledge that some of them will attempt to plagiarize?
Preventing plagiarism
- Clearly define plagiarism at the beginning of the semester, ideally in the syllabus
-
- Teaching students about academic integrity is an opportunity to help them understand how to take part and influence the academic conversation.
- When students can effectively build on others’ ideas, they become more aware and comfortable with their own ideas, as well as feel a sense of responsibility to the academic community they are contributing to.
- Refer to this student guide on documentation and plagiarism – https://www.skidmore.edu/writing_guide/documentation.php
- Reference the Skidmore Academic Honor Code and the statement on academic integrity
- Academic integrity checklist for students
- Include a clear distinction between acceptable forms of collaboration and plagiarism
- Creativity and exploration are important, we don’t want to stifle these by being overly punitive. Be careful when setting the tone around this issue, striking the right balance is not always easy.
- Teaching students about academic integrity is an opportunity to help them understand how to take part and influence the academic conversation.
-
- Provide examples of proper citation
-
- Give students examples of when it is necessary to cite others and what citation method they should use.
-
- Create assignments that encourage originality and discourage plagiarism
- Assessments that are formative, smaller and more frequent, and face to face when possible.
-
- As opposed to a single large summative assessment
- Design assessments so students can show that they’ve learned, not to catch cheaters
-
- Modify assessments from semester to semester
- Request photocopies of all sources used in a paper
- Make clear that all written assignments will be submitted to an automated plagiarism service, ie Turnitin.
Assignments for deterring plagiarism
- Give students a low-stakes writing assignment to begin the semester; for example, where they introduce themselves to the instructor and classmates via a discussion board. This can provide a good baseline writing sample in the student’s natural voice, for later comparison if necessary.
- Craft writing assignments that are not easily plagiarized, such as asking for unique, specific, and/or personal insights instead of more general information about a topic.
- Use scaffolded writing assignments (e.g., proposal, annotated bibliography, and multiple drafts)
Plagiarism warning signs
- Writing that seems inconsistent with the level of the class and/or previous examples of the student’s writing
- Inconsistent writing style, with sophisticated and unrefined sentences mixed together
- Bibliography is unclear or has sources missing
Other resources on plagiarism
MIT – http://cmsw.mit.edu/writing-and-communication-center/resources/teachers/detect-plagiarism/
Carnegie Mellon – https://www.cmu.edu/teaching/designteach/design/instructionalstrategies/writing/preventplagiarism.html
Northwestern – http://www.northwestern.edu/provost/policies/academic-integrity/how-to-avoid-plagiarism.html
Automated Plagiarism & AI Detection with Turnitin
Using Turnitin in theSpring
See this document for step-by-step instructions on how to create an assignment in theSpring with Turnitin enabled.
By enabling the Similarity Report for your assignments in theSpring Turnitin also automatically checks for AI generated text. For more information about how to utilize Turnitin’s AI detection tool, have a look at this webpage, https://help.turnitin.com/ai-writing-detection.htm. See the Turnitin FAQ page for more information about how Turnitin’s AI detection functions, https://www.turnitin.com/products/features/ai-writing-detection.
The Similarity Report explained
Turnitin Instructor User Manual
Accessing Turnitin Directly
For those not using theSpring who would still like to utilize Turnitin, you will first need to request a new Turnitin account be created for you, and then follow these instructions. If you have used Turnitin in the past via theSpring or Blackboard, but this is your first time accessing Turnitin directly, use your Skidmore email address and click on Forgot Password to get one set up. Once logged in you may first need to activate the Quick Submit feature. And then you can submit your student paper(s) using Quick Submit.
Turnitin Resources
Turnitin Instructor User Manual (for use in theSpring)
Instructor Quick Start guide (using Turnitin directly)
Link to Recorded Skidmore Turnitin Training Session
Office
Hours
Feel free to swing by during our normal office hours or schedule an appointment